Christian Petronelli

$8.4 Million Employment Verdict: Trial Strategy Breakdown – Byer v. La Palma

What does it take to obtain an $8.4 million verdict in an employment case with:

  • Constructive termination
  • No economic damages
  • A short employment period
  • A variety of alleged performance issues
  • Prior trauma in the plaintiff’s history
  • Conservative venue (Orange County Superior Court)

In Byer v. City of La Palma, the jury awarded $3.92 million in past and $4.48 million in future non-economic damages for race discrimination, retaliation, and failure to prevent discrimination and retaliation.

This one-hour lecture provides a step-by-step breakdown of how that result was achieved, utilizing resources available to anyone through TLU On Demand.

This lecture will discuss:

  • Establishing liability through defense witnesses
  • Neutralizing “performance issues” and reframing them as a pretext
  • Humanizing the plaintiff through prior emotional trauma/distress
  • Preparing and delivering an opening that sets the tone for liability and damages
  • Structuring the retaliation timeline so escalation becomes undeniable
  • Presenting non-economic damages in a way that feels justified and logical

Attendees will leave with a practical framework for trying employment cases that appear modest on paper—but contain significant verdict potential when properly developed.

If you want a concrete breakdown of how strategy, preparation, and disciplined storytelling produced an $8.4 million verdict, this session delivers it.

TLU Live HB Agenda

TLU Live HB Parties & Activities

Tuesday Activities

Supio Logo

Pickleball

2:00pm-4:00pm

Fellerman And Ciarimboli Logo

Surfcamp with Fellerman & Ciarimboli

2:00pm-4:00pm

Dan Surfing
Finch Logo300 Logo

Welcome Dinner
at Lōrea

6:00pm

Lōrea