Case had its venue in Supreme Court, Bronx County, in New York City.
The case arose from a trip and fall accident that occurred on March 4, 2017, in the Visual Arts Center at Sarah Lawrence College in Bronxville, N.Y.

Although comparative fault was a big issue in the case and at trial, the jury found 100% fault against Sarah Lawrence College and determined that Ms. Bako did not cause or contribute to the accident.

With respect to negotiation, the College’s insurer refused to make any significant offer before trial. At trial, the Judge attempted to negotiate a settlement and recommended that the carrier offer $1 Million Dollars to resolve the case, but they refused, and the matter proceeded to trial.
In March, 2017, Yolanda Bako was a 71 year-old retired woman who lived alone on a meager fixed income in the Bronx. Although she was retired from various clerical positions, in her earlier years Ms. Bako was very active in the Women’s Rights Movement, participating in various initiatives and protests, particularly in the area of protecting women from domestic violence.

On March 4, 2017, Ms. Bako visited Sarah Lawrence College to attend a Women’s History Conference that the College hosted annually. After a luncheon in the College’s Visual Arts Center, Ms. Bako was walking to an elevator to attend an afternoon session seminar when she tripped on the base of an art installation that was on display. She fell to the floor.
Although she was helped up and briefly attended her seminar, she soon asked for help and EMTs were called to the scene. She was taken to the hospital and diagnosed with a minimally displaced right hip fracture that required open reduction internal fixation surgery. After this surgery, she had a poor recovery and developed some complications that added to her damages and resulted in two additional surgeries.

From the initial fracture and ORIF surgery, Ms. Bako developed a significant re-activation and aggravation of a preexisting incontinence problem which made her stays in the hospital and rehab facilities very uncomfortable. Despite treatment, this bladder control condition persisted and was claimed as a complication from the original hip injury.
Because of her age and frail bones, the ORIF surgery failed and she underwent right hip joint replacement surgery approximately three months after the initial trauma.

Approximately two years later, Ms. Bako underwent joint replacement surgery for her other hip, the left side, which was not injured in the accident. Nonetheless, we claimed the left hip replacement, arguing that it was a consequential /secondary injury stemming from the original injury to the other hip. Specifically, we alleged that the original fracture and two surgeries on the right side destabilized her entire pelvis and caused accelerated degeneration /collapse of the left side, necessitating a joint replacement surgery that otherwise would not have been necessary.

As Ms. Bako was retired, no lost earnings claim was alleged. We did have a life care plan that included home care and totaled just over $3.6 Million.
Ms. Bako had an extensive, well-documented prior medical history that included osteoarthritis throughout her body, joint pain, hand and foot pain, pain throughout her body, spine pain, insomnia, incontinence, nocturia, and depression. In the year before the accident, she had applied for disability transportation services, saying that she was too infirm to use public transit.

The defense disputed liability, arguing that the condition was “open and obvious,” violated no safety standards and was easily avoidable. The College alleged that Ms. Bako was not paying attention, walked into the art installation and caused her own accident.

On damages, the defense argued that most/all of her complaints and limitations were related to her age-related preexisting conditions, that the incontinence was preexisting and entirely unrelated to the accident, and that her left hip replacement surgery was from old age and also unrelated to the accident. The College argued that Ms. Bako’s own medical records indicated that before this accident happened she was already suffering with pain, lacking mobility, and in need of medical/home care. On this basis, they alleged that the life care plan was excessive and unrelated to the injuries caused by the accident.

Strategies & Tactics Used at Trial – Discussion Points:

*Winning the Comparative Fault Fight by Acknowledging Plaintiff’s Role in the Accident

*Contrasting Plaintiff’s Acknowledgement against Defendant’s Denial of Fault

*Overcoming your Weaknesses by Admitting Them and Giving Them Proper Context

*Beyond the Admission of Weaknesses – Weaving the Weakness into your Story

*Taking Advantage of How Defendant Blames Your Client on Liability & Damages

*Showing How the Blaming Starting at the Accident and Continued Through Trial

*Elderly, Infirm Clients and the Egg Shell Plaintiff

*Establishing Your Credibility and the Reasonableness of Your Position

*Putting the Defense on Trial – Exposing the Fallacy of Denial and Blame

Embracing the Preexisting Conditions & Increased Susceptibility

Photos Tell the Story and Corroborate the Testimony

PREPARATION OF THE PLAINTIFF TO TESTIFY EFFECTIVELY –

Turning an Unfavorable Accident Report into your Best Friend

Telling Your Story Through the Defense Witness

Showing the Absurdity of the Defense Position

Gain Ammunition for the Argument about Defense Motive

Shifting from Shared Responsibility to the Total Win Based on the Evidence

Calling out the Defense Tactics and Getting the Jury Displeased with the

Steve Williamson

Nathan Werksman

$10,000,000 Trip and Fall Verdict

Jennifer Gore-Cuthbert

Growing and Scaling your Law Firm – Hiring Key People/Building a Leadership Team 

Dan Ambrose

Giorgio Panagos

Raj Guha

TLU Skills Bootcamp

Darryl Isaacs

Andrew Finkelstein

Building Your Billion Dollar Empire

William Barton

David Clark

Dark Art Trial Craft

David deRubertis

deRubertis Employment College

Dale Gaplipo

Working Up A Civil Rights Case Before Trial

Phillip Miller

Edward Ciarimboli

Thomas Vesper

Advanced Deposition Strategy and Practice

Brian Breiter

Joseph Limbaugh

Improv for Trial

Cliff Atkinson

Visual Advocacy/PowerPoint Mastery Bootcamp

Bruce Schechter

Khail Parris

Translating An Effective Deposition Into A Killer Cross

Depositions Are Trial - Taking Effective Depositions To Win Your Case Before Ever Seeing A Jury

Jason Fowler

Daniel Eli

Understanding Bad Faith and Breaches of the Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing

R. Rex Parris

Being An Effective Closer - Justifying A Big Verdict To Twelve Friends (Closings)

Bankruptcy Hour - What To Do When The Carrier Screws The Insured By Convincing Them To Declare Bankruptcy

What To Do When An Insurance Carrier Denies Coverage, Coverage Denial May Not Be The End, But Rather An Opportunity

Alex Wheeler

Becoming a Master Trial Lawyer

The Business Mechanics of Litigating Cases: The Real Reason Cases are being under settled

Daniel Kramer

Clash Of The Titans

Tricia Bigelow

Monique Ngo-Bonnici

Kitty K. Szeto

Eve and Adam: Finding the Serpents and the Fruit of the Poisonous Tree in the Legal Profession

Justin Kahn

Visualizing The Case - Start thinking and presenting visually

Judicial Hour

The Perfect Opening

Preparing Your Client To Face Their Fears In Order To Testify Effectively

The Art Of Picking A Jury Vol 2

The Art of Picking A Jury Vol 1

Adam Malone

3 Essential Skills for Winning Medical Negligence Cases

Brett Schreiber

Dangerous Property Cases From Inception to Verdict

Keith More

Workers Comp Crossover Cases: How to spot them, overcome Privette, and eliminate liens in your PI case

How To Win a Civil Rights Case At Trial

Bring Your File

Bibi Fell

Workshop Your Upcoming Case – Brainstorming Frames, Themes, Visuals & Voir Dire Questions

Get Up and Present

Brent Savage

Finding Your Damages Case

Christian Morris

The Science and Technique of Cross Examination

Jack Denove

Effective Non-Verbal Communication

Taking the Winning Deposition from the Defendant Doctor

Preparing Your Client for Deposition

Kurt Zaner

Openings according to Cicero, 2000 year-old techniques applied today

Premises

Wordless Persuasion: The Neuroscience-Based Skills that Provide the Key to Connection with Jurors.

Defense Tactics Used to Stop Nuclear Verdicts

Adante Pointer

Stephen King

Mastering Storytelling in Personal Injury and Civil Rights Cases

Negotiating with Emotional Intelligence

Steve Linder

Kurt Kerns

Science of Persuasion

Lloyd Bell

Laura Shamp

Winning Before Trial - Building Your Medical Malpractice Case For Success in the Courtroom

Rahul Ravipudi

Fine Tune Your Jury Deselection Strategy

Greg Bentley

Clare Lucich

Dangerous Condition Cases

How to use dramatic/theatrical techniques in opening and closing

Jonathan Michaels

Cross Examination of the Accident Reconstruction Expert

Voir Dire Skills Training: Bring Your Case!

Opening and Closing

Understanding and Influencing the 84 Jurors

Rob Ammons

Win Your Case Before Trial and How to Try it if They Let You

Nate Bjerke

Witness Prep

Haytham Faraj

Katherine Melik-Stepanyan

Preparing The Winning Case From Intake To Verdict

Michael Blom

Brett Findler

Mass Torts and Tax Credits; Non-Recourse Litigation and Medical Care Funding

Joe Fried

Sach Oliver

Negotiation Mastery

How to effectively use visuals at deposition and trial

Greyson Goody

Edwin Hong

A.I. 101: The Automation and Transformation of Law

Dirk Vandever

Dirk's Dozen Voir Dire Questions

USA Express Legal and Investigative Services Inc.

 Iconographics

Sweet James

Paramount Focus Groups

Mirena & Co

BluShark Digital

Advanced Projector Technologies

On the Map

iLawyers Marketing & Alert Communications

MLG Attorneys at Law

TLU Trial Skills Bootcamps

Consumer Attorney Record Services

Trial Lawyers University

Vinetegrate

CASEpeer

3D Forensic

Procare Funding

Advocate Capital, Inc

Rize Up Media

Allrise

ChartSquad

Golden Pear Funding

Intaker

Brain Trust Legal

4 Corners Deposition Summaries

Expert MRI

FoxAE

Gerrel 1 Button

HMR Servicing

Assembly Legal

National Record Retrieval

Gemini Legal

Advocacy Digital Media

Case Status

Smart Advocate

Walker Advertising

Independent Life

Priority Responsible Funding

TSEG

Focus Graphics

Stratejic Relationships

Bell Law Firm

Formula Call Center

Trial Lawyer Nation

Filevine

TLU Podcast

Claggett & Sykes

TLU On Demand

Trial Template

EvenUp

Law Rank

MedQuest Ltd

Emotion Trac

Hona

R. Rex Parris

Khail Parris

Alex Wheeler

Jason Fowler

Dan Eli

Brian Panish

Dan Ambrose

Sean Claggett

Joseph Fried

Lloyd Bell

Edward Ciarimboli

Ibiere Seck

Kurt Zaner

Christian Morris

Rahul Ravipudi

Jonathan Michaels

Darryl Isaacs

John Romano

Nicholas Wooldridge

Stephen King

Giorgio Panagos

Ranojoy Guha

Sach Oliver

Phillip Miller

Patrick Salvi

Dale Galipo

David DeRubertis

Greg Bentley

David Clark

Clare Lucich

Haytham Faraj

Adante Pointer

Nick Rowley

Gary A. Dordick

Robert T. Simon

Evan Garcia

Sagi Shaked

Stephen J. Burg

Conal Doyle

Steven DeBosier

Tom Thomas Metier

Michael Cowen

Benjamin P. Cloward

Ben B. Rubinowitz

Navan Ward

Mohamad Ahmad

Ray Kermani

Jessica Brylo

Bruce Broillet

Molly McKibben

Chris Dolan

Chad Dudley

Michael Hill

Justin Kahn

Mark Kosieradzki

Przemek Lubecki

Dr. Hector Miranda

Craig Peters

Randall Sorrels

Dirk Vandever

Kimball Jones

Jakob Norman

Steve Hohman

Olivia Espinosa

Mauro Fiore

Chris Vander Kaay

Joon Hong

Michael Alder

Christian Augustin

Will Sykes

Jim Murphy

Brian Blankenship

Geordan Logan

Shannon Wise

Jennifer Morales

Micah Echols

Charlie Finlayson

Matt Granda

David Snyder

Dorothy Clay Sims